The Secretary of Defense (now titled the Secretary of War), Pete Hegsteth (former talk show host on FOX), summoned 800 Admirals and Generals from all over the world to Quantico, Virginia, yesterday for a pep talk. Not to be outdone by the secretary, Trump, unwilling to see someone else become the center of attention, appeared and took the stage. Mind you, these 800 officers, many of whom are highly educated, graduates from military academies like West Point and Annapolis, were forced to hear the inanities of a talk show host and a reality TV star, neither of whom possesses a scintilla of intelligence, wit, or wisdom. It had to be excruciating, for the officers, after flying thousands of miles to endure the idiocies of a draft dodger and an alcoholic as they lecture these esteemed officers on the warrior ethos. No fiction writer could conceive of such a thing, but in Trumpworld the inconceivable becomes reality.
The grandson of General Lucian Truscott, a journalist, Lucian Truscott IV, attended the lecture. He had this to write:
“Unhinged” is one word I heard on the news shows describing Trump’s speech this morning. So is “bonkers.” One report called Trump “meandering” and “exhausted.” But no description could capture what took place in Quantico, Virginia this morning. All the papers and cable shows and commentators are talking about how Trump said he wants “dangerous cities” led by Democrats to be used as “training grounds” for the military, and that was on obvious outrage among many others, but I want to begin with Trump’s disquisition on walking up and down stairs.
He began by attacking Biden, naturally, complaining that “We were not respected with Biden. They looked at him falling down stairs every day – every day, the guy’s falling down stairs – and I said, that’s not our president. We can’t have it. I’m very careful, you know, when I walk down stairs, I walk…very…slowly. Nobody has to set a record. Just, try not to fall, ‘cause it doesn’t work out well. A few of our presidents have fallen, and it became a part of their legacy, you know. Walk nice and easy. You don’t have to set any records. Be cool! Be cool when you walk down, but don’t…don’t bop down the stairs. The one thing with Obama…I had zero respect for him as a president, but he would bop down those stairs, I’ve never seen…da-da-da-da-teh-deh-bop-bop…I’ve never seen…he would go down those stairs, bop-bop, he wouldn’t hold on, he’d go down those stairs, I said, it’s great! I wouldn’t want to do it. I guess I could do it, but eventually, bad things are gonna happen, and it only takes one. A year ago, we were a dead country. We were dead. This country was going to hell. We had nothing.”
He went on. And on. And on. Seventy minutes, he blathered through his usual patter of lies, bigger lies, grievance, self-pity, and self adoration. I watched the speech, and he must have said the word “Biden” 30 times. It’s not really worth quoting any more of his lies and nonsense, because you’ve heard it before, heard it too many times.
So had the generals and admirals and noncommissioned officers. They are citizens. They either live in the United States, or they’re stationed overseas where American broadcasts are available via satellite. They know a rally speech when they hear one, and they knew that is what they had been ordered to travel great distances to listen to today. One report noted that the audience of the most senior uniformed officers in our military sat “stone-faced” through the whole thing, with only a momentary chuckle from a few in the audience at something Trump said. There was no applause during the speech despite the fact that Trump hit all his applause points like he does at his rallies.
It’s the bragging and exaggeration that must have really gotten to them. I ended eight wars! The pull out from Afghanistan was the worst day in the history of our country. I did this. I did that. Biden was the worst president. The Democrats don’t respect you and will never treat you right.
Trump seemed oblivious to the fact that everyone in that auditorium, during careers of as many as 30 years, had served under not only Biden, but Trump and Obama and Bush and Clinton. Most of them had seen combat. Most of them had their own experience with “the worst day” on the battlefield or in training accidents. They know that the Marines and the Army have had helicopter accidents that killed more soldiers in a single training incident than died in the terror attack in Kabul that killed 13 which Trump referred to.
In the culture of the U.S. military, generals and admirals don’t brag about themselves. The only bragging that is done by commanders in the military is about the accomplishments of the troops who serve under them. Not one of those generals or admirals had ever stood up before an audience in the military and cried out look at me! I’m the greatest! Look at all I’ve done!
Unseemly is not an adequate word to describe how generals and admirals and senior NCOs consider bragging. They don’t do it, and they don’t put up with it from others who serve with them.
I have concluded that today’s display of ego and bluster and falsehoods by Hegseth and Trump may have served a useful purpose after all. Every one of those generals and admirals and senior noncommissioned officers now has had personal experience with who they serve under. None of them could have missed the sexism in Hegseth’s speech when he told them that the military is “going back to male standards” for combat soldiers. All of them know that female soldiers have earned Ranger status by enduring the exact same hardships male soldiers endure. All of them know that women fly jets off and onto the pitching decks of aircraft carriers in dangerous seas. The Coast Guard admirals know that female officers command the same rescue boats that go out in impossible weather every day.
There were Black generals and admirals sitting amidst their white counterparts in that audience in Quantico today. Not one of them, white or Black, could have missed the rank racism when Trump imitated Barack Obama “bopping” down a set of stairs. Trump said he “never seen” anything like it, as if he were describing a tight end in a football game catching a difficult pass. None of them missed the racism when Trump mentioned, in speaking about “the nuclear” that there are two “N-words” you can’t say. Every person in that room knew what the other N-word is, and they got it that Trump was complaining that “political correct,” as he called it, had stopped its usage.
The really sad thing about what transpired in Quantico today is that there is no one in Trump’s White House or among the top civilian command at the Pentagon or for that matter in the entire Republican Party who thinks there was anything wrong with anything said by either Hegseth or Trump. But generals and admirals endured George Bush and the lies he told that forced them into a war they knew was bogus. They endured his absurd “mission accomplished” moment when everyone in the military knew that precisely nothing had been “accomplished” a few months into the war in Iraq. They knew from reading history that this country and its military had been forced into a war in Vietnam on the basis of another ocean of lies.
In the end, the generals and admirals know that presidents come and go, but their job remains the same. The soldiers, sailors, airmen and airwomen and Marines under their command need them to do their jobs in spite of the madness at the top. Their loyalty is to the Constitution, not to President Donald Trump and Secretary of Whatever the Hell He Thinks He Is Pete Hegseth.
They will endure. So will we.”
Imagining these officers realizing (if they hadn’t already) that the partisan dimwits speaking before them can direct them to do whatever the dimwits want them to do, I wonder whether they now feel it is incumbent upon them to act. So does another writer, Ellis Hovey, who wrote:
“Our greatest hope for our democracy should right now be that 800 of the world's greatest military minds are flying back to their posts with solid realizations that it is up to them to save this country from the current totally corrupt administration.
Or will these military generals go into self preservationist mode, ignore their oath, and say to hell with the country?
The situation—800 military leaders grappling with their oath versus the pressures of a potentially corrupt administration—is layered with complexity. Historically, the U.S. military's loyalty is deeply rooted in its oath to defend the Constitution, not any individual leader. This oath is a cornerstone of military service, emphasizing allegiance to the nation and its democratic framework rather than personal loyalty to a president or administration.
However, the actions of military leaders in such scenarios depend on their adherence to this oath and their interpretation of their role within the chain of command. Some may feel compelled to speak out or take action if they perceive constitutional principles are under threat. Others might prioritize stability, fearing that direct confrontation could lead to chaos or undermine the institution they serve. Military professionals are trained to remain apolitical, but moments of political or ethical crisis can test this neutrality.”
I post this because I want a record of what is happening in American in October, 2025. Historians will have their sources. Perhaps my descendants will have this.